
Mr. Kennedy is back in WWE. He isn’t back to wrestle, at least for now, but under a legends contract that he revealed on Saturday during an interview at The Big Event in New York.
The news is good, but it’s impossible to hear Kennedy’s name without thinking about the biggest “what if” of that era in WWE.
Here’s what happened.
Kennedy won the Money in the Bank ladder match at WrestleMania 23 in Detroit, in a match that also included Edge, Randy Orton, CM Punk, Finlay, Booker T and The Hardys. Plans called for him to hold the briefcase for a full year and cash it in at WrestleMania 24. He even announced it on RAW.
However, The Undertaker then suffered a torn biceps, and WWE needed to get the world title off him quickly.
The fix was simple. After The Undertaker’s steel cage match against Batista on SmackDown, Kennedy would come out, cash in the briefcase and leave as champion. According to Kennedy, Vince and Stephanie McMahon were the ones who told him the plan.
A few days earlier, however, at a house show in Poughkeepsie, Kennedy took a clothesline from Batista and felt something pop in his triceps. WWE doctors said he had torn the tendon off the bone, which would keep him out of action for five to seven months.
WWE wasted no time. On Monday, May 7, 2007, the company sent a private jet to bring Kennedy to RAW at Penn State. He lost the briefcase to Edge, who went on to do exactly what had been planned for Kennedy on SmackDown that same week.
The worst part came later. Kennedy traveled to Birmingham, Alabama, to see Dr. James Andrews, who told him directly, “That’s not a tear.” It turned out to be a big hematoma, and his recovery time dropped to four or five weeks.
The Mistake That Cost Him the World Title
I’m not saying anyone acted in bad faith. Let’s be honest, though. Taking the briefcase off a guy in the middle of a weekend, before anyone knew for sure what was wrong with him, was making the call too soon. Granted, the title had to come off Undertaker. Kennedy, however, was a few weeks away from a return, not half a year.
MVP summed it up better than anyone when he told Kennedy:
“You were a misdiagnosis away from becoming World Champion.”
I know some will argue Kennedy’s career wasn’t going to go far anyway. After that came the storyline involving the illegitimate son of Vince McMahon, which was scrapped due to a suspension. He dealt with more injuries before being released in 2009. Yes, he did go on to become a two-time world champion in TNA.
None of that changes what happened that week, though. Edge walked out with the first World Heavyweight Championship of his career and took off from there. Kennedy lost his moment and never had another one like it in WWE.
In pro wrestling, momentum isn’t something you can buy back later.
Now, with the legends contract signed, he has named CM Punk and Roman Reigns as two stars he would like to face. Personally, I think it’s unlikely. The contract doesn’t give him that briefcase back, but at least it puts his name back with the company where he nearly reached the top.