
WWE has turned the choice of the fifth member of Team USA into a complete mystery. After Damian Priest took Trick Williams out of action on the latest SmackDown, Cody Rhodes assured CM Punk that he already had a replacement in mind, but he kept the name under wraps.
The announcement will take place on Monday’s Raw, five days before Survivor Series. With Rhodes, Punk, LA Knight, and Je’Von Evans already confirmed, the final choice could reveal what the real direction of this storyline is going to be. And some candidates would do a lot more than just fill the final spot on the team.
This ranking is based on the impact each pick would have on the relationship between Rhodes and Punk, as well as the storyline possibilities after Survivor Series.
R-Truth

R-Truth’s return to a traditional Survivor Series match would be a pretty safe choice, especially after WWE used Jim Duggan and Danhausen to play up the comedy side of the search for the team’s final member.
There is one detail, however, that could make this an interesting choice. R-Truth was Priest’s tag team partner for much of 2026. The two won the WWE Tag Team Championship in March and lost the titles to MFT in August. Priest was the very man who took Williams out of Survivor Series.
This would allow WWE to use the recent history between the former tag team partners, especially if R-Truth showed he was unhappy with Priest’s actions.
Chad Gable

Chad Gable has an advantage over almost all of the other candidates. His presence would allow WWE to build a feud within the match itself, without having to depend solely on the conflict between the captains.
Gable, a former Intercontinental Champion, had a lengthy storyline with El Grande Americano, including a Mask vs. Mask match in AAA in May. The possibility of Americano taking the fifth spot on Team Mexico would create a chance to reignite that feud in a different way.
Bully Ray has even suggested the idea publicly. Gable is also a choice that makes sense for the American theme of the match, given his Olympic background and the amateur wrestling style he uses.
Damian Priest

Priest would probably be the most controversial pick on this list. After all, he was the one who caused the injury that forced Rhodes to look for another partner.
On Friday’s SmackDown, he hit Williams in the knee with the ring bell, getting himself disqualified. After that, he continued the attack, which led to Nick Aldis ruling Williams, the reigning United States Champion, out of Survivor Series.
WWE could take advantage of that attack. If Priest was interested in earning a spot in the match, his attack would have led to exactly the result he needed to open one up.
Rhodes would then be facing a tough decision. If he accepted Priest, he would be rewarding the man responsible for hurting his team. Turning him down would mean giving up a former world champion in a time of need.
This possibility is less likely, mainly because the company seems to be building towards a feud between Priest and Williams for the United States Championship more than anything else.
The Rock

The Rock‘s appearance at Survivor Series is already confirmed. On Wednesday’s episode of The Pat McAfee Show, The Great One announced that he’ll be in Houston on Saturday, right when WWE will celebrate 30 years since his in-ring debut, which came at Survivor Series 1996.
For now, though, there has been no confirmation that he will wrestle.
However, adding him to Team USA would give the company an opportunity to connect two stories. In 2025, The Rock tried to convince Rhodes to become his champion, an offer that culminated in John Cena turning on The American Nightmare at Elimination Chamber, as we remember well.
A partnership between Rhodes and The Rock for one night, even if it’s temporary, could be a step forward in a rivalry that, at the moment, seems like it will never end. On top of that, The Rock is no stranger to this type of match, and including him for one night could have nothing to do with Rhodes, but rather with his story of overcoming the odds at Survivor Series.
So, even though he’s the name that could be involved in big surprises, it’s unlikely that he’ll be the fifth member.
Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins has just about everything needed to be announced as the final member of Team USA. Especially after what Rhodes said at the end of SmackDown.
When Punk asked who would replace Williams, Rhodes responded by asking how badly The Best in the World really wanted to win. That line suggests that the choice will require some personal sacrifice, something that fits perfectly with the long history of the feud between Punk and Rollins.
The two have years of bad blood between them. In August 2025, for example, Rollins used his Money in the Bank briefcase to take the World Heavyweight Championship from Punk, a few minutes after Punk beat Gunther.
Rollins has been off TV since his loss to Roman Reigns at SummerSlam in August. His name even showed up in the promotional material for Monday’s Raw, although that doesn’t mean he’s automatically returning.
The choice would allow Rhodes to finally take control of the team, going against Punk’s position as co-captain. The big draw, though, would be in the match itself. Having Punk and Rollins as partners would create tension within Team USA itself, which could be a good draw for the match.
That’s why Rollins takes the top spot. His presence would justify the question Rhodes asked, explain the mystery around the announcement, and give WWE a story to build on after Survivor Series.